Crypto Must Apply Safety Lessons of the Existing Financial System
There is a revealing, albeit slightly morbid, maxim that “safety standards are written in blood.” Humans and human-created systems generally tend to be reactive rather than proactive when it comes to developing protective rules. Nevertheless, today’s construction workers and consumers are more shielded from danger than those of the past because we’ve learned from prior mistakes.
Rick McDonell was the executive secretary of the Financial Action Task Force from 2007 until 2016. Prior to that, he was chief of the United Nations Global Program against Money Laundering at the UNODC. He is now executive director of ACAMS, the Association of Certified Anti-Money Laundering Specialists.
The same dynamic exists in financial regulation, where it could be said that “financial standards are written in fraud.” For example, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission didn’t exist in the first iterations of the stock market. It was only after “Black Tuesday,” the 1929 stock market crash so severe that it was a major contributing factor to the Great Depression, that new laws and regulations were introduced that continue to define modern finance. But the world has morphed into two: the real world and the virtual world. The old rules do not suit either of them.
Parts of the cryptocurrency industry have been culturally slow to accept and implement compliance requirements of the existing (traditional) financial system. This extends from basic know-your-customer (KYC) protocols to the more challenging requirements of the “Travel Rule.” Companies offering services in the crypto industry – commonly called “virtual asset service providers,” or VASPs – need to comply in full force and spirit with global anti-money laundering and counter-terrorism financing conventions or risk being sanctioned or shut out by regulators or criminally pursued by law enforcement if they intentionally breach the law in jurisdictions in which they reside or operate.
For example, the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN), a U.S.-based regulator that is also a bellwether of global financial regulatory enforcement, recently proposed lowering the threshold of the Travel Rule from $3,000 to $250.
See also: Campbell-Verduyn/Moritz Hutten – Is the Travel Rule Good or Bad for Crypto? Both
The Travel Rule requires financial institutions transferring money across international borders to collect and share certain information about the sender and recipient. It is a key tool in the fight against money laundering, terrorism financing, transnational criminal activity and fraud. VASPs that create on-ramps to the crypto economy, enabling the exchange of fiat money for crypto, are clearly a critical link in effective enforcement of the Travel Rule.
It is not lost on regulators that cryptocurrencies, with an ability to transmit value instantly outside the rails of the traditional financial system, present special challenges when it comes to complying with this rule. The existing financial system sits within a reporting framework that enables enforcement of the Travel Rule. Crypto does not.
VASPS SHOULD BE PREPARED TO BE HELD TO THE SAME STANDARDS AS THE REST OF THE FINANCIAL SYSTEM.
Beyond the hundreds of active distributed protocols transferring millions of dollars worth of digital currencies every second, many blockchains tie up value in complex arrangements like decentralized finance (DeFi), layer 2 protocols, sidechains and smart contracts. It is no small challenge to retrofit a system designed for information sharing between centralized, regulated entities to a web of decentralized networks where anyone with an internet connection can participate.
That doesn’t absolve VASPs of responsibility. On the contrary, it makes their participation in enforcing existing rules all the more critical.
Crypto has a perception problem in many countries – created in part by a historical association with ransomware extortionists, exchange hacks, dark web merchants and sanction-evading nations. U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen recently expressed concerns over bitcoin’s association with illicit activities. In a recent survey, more than half of respondents among government and financial compliance professionals said crypto was a risk to the financial system, yet 80% of crypto industry insiders viewed crypto as an opportunity. Clearly, there is much more work to be done to close the gap.
Vocal support from VASPs for a consistent, regulatory regime, such as one outlined by industry advocacy group Coin Center, is one step that industry supporters could take to demonstrate a commitment to legitimacy.
On the other hand, governments should be aggressive in prosecuting VASPs that resist regulatory oversight. The recent enforcement action brought against Tether demonstrates why regulators need to shine a spotlight on this area. In this arena, there is little difference from the traditional finance world. Pursuing bad actors improves faith in the entire system, and deters potential criminal activity in the future.
If VASPs take the concerns of regulators seriously and demonstrate concerted, good-faith efforts to comply with the international financial crime enforcement regime, governments will be more willing to recognize the legitimate, unique benefits cryptocurrencies offer: accessibility, financial inclusion, programmable money and more.
The modern global financial system is one of humanity’s greatest feats of social and economic engineering, centuries in the making. Despite its flaws, it has helped foster an unprecedented era of global economic activity and stability. If the cryptocurrency industry and governments can work together to apply the lessons learned in the painstaking development of the current system, the financial system of the future will be more fair, more productive, more efficient and more accessible than ever before.
Practically speaking, governments have very little incentive to change the rules to accommodate crypto but have significant incentive to insist on a level playing field with traditional financial institutions. While cryptocurrencies and virtual assets are digital, the reality is that VASPs still need to operate out of countries. Governments might be behind the curve on crypto but they are quickly catching up, and VASPs should be prepared to be held to the same standards as the rest of the financial system.
Recommended News
-
Fintoch Education: Crypto Custody
Fintoch is an innovative blockchain financial platform built by Morgan DF Fintoch. In the very beginning, the positioning of Fintoch is set to be something big – an ecosystem that connects lenders, borrowers, traders, and investors alike. A lively financial ecosystem is only viable if the underlying security for user funds is solid. Remember in Crypto, we don’t trust but verify. With that said, Fintoch focused on the development of its core technology HyBriid 2.0, which combines “zero-knowledge proof” and “multiple signatures” to protect users’ funds. For users who are…
-
WEB3.0’s first war why FSV is the main field
According to the data survey, it was found that in the current hot wind of the meta-universe, “whether it is a big factory or a startup team, more and more people are entering Web3.0 throughout 2022.” In the promotion of capital and various institutions, the star project FSV in 2022 also began to build FSVSWAP based on FSV smart chain, is expected to complete all main network testing and successful launch in Q4 2022, this FSV build FSVSWAP engine page based on FSV smart chain also marks the era of…
-
Crypto Exchange Coinsquare Ordered to Hand Thousands of Customers’ Records to Canadian Tax Agency
Canada’s tax authority, the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) has prevailed in a court battle for access to a trove of high-value customer data held by cryptocurrency exchange Coinsquare. And the CRA seems to be coming for more. Under a federal judge’s March 19 order, Coinsquare must hand over detailed information on its Canadian customers, their crypto trading activity and identifying information to the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA). Coinsquare told CoinDesk that it will disclose information on an estimated 5% to 10% of its 400,000 customers to the CRA, which had originally…
-
How does GameFi+DEFI drive the blockchain games industry upgrade?
If 2020 is the first year of DeFi outbreak, then 2021 is undoubtedly the first year of GameFi blockchain games outbreak. According to DappRadar’s statistics, on April 18th, 2021, the number of transactions in the blockchain games sector was as high as 480.7 billion dollars. As of July 31st, the number of users in the blockchain games sector exceeded 780,000, an increase of more than 170 times compared with the beginning of the year, and the number of daily active wallets in GameFi increased by 700% from March to July….
-
What is the origin of the capitalist FTS that has set the NFT market alight?
The world’s progress is a process of subversion and re-subversion, innovation and re-innovation, however, every epoch-making technological revolution has fundamentally advanced the progress of human civilization,, with Bitcoin’s ten-year 26 million investment income, and created numerous wealth myths in just a few years, the emergence of Bitcoin has also made the decentralized distributed ledger blockchain technology popular worldwide , making Bitcoin gradually The fourth industrial revolution, with blockchain as its core, will bring unprecedented changes to humanity. NFT (TNon-Fungible Token), a digital cryptocurrency on the blockchain, is divided into…
-
Market Wrap: Bitcoin Stuck Below $50K, and Blockchain Data May Show Why
Bitcoin ended the first week of March with little fanfare as the market reset after the prior week’s 21% plunge. There are more signs the global economic recovery might come faster than previously expected, and traders are speculating on what that might mean for the largest cryptocurrency. Bitcoin (BTC) trading around $49,196.78 as of 21:00 UTC (4 p.m. ET). Climbing 1.93% over the previous 24 hours. Bitcoin’s 24-hour range: $46,393.39-$49,462.13 (CoinDesk 20) BTC trades above its 10-hour and 50-hour averages on the hourly chart, a bullish signal for market technicians. Bitcoin trading…
-
European royal noble favorite essential oil workshop Estrella Choelus
“Estrella Choelus,” translated from ancient Greek as “Estrella Chœlus,” originally meant a star that was permanent, pleasant, and beautiful.In 1844, while refining essential oils, Galio di Vincenzo, a vegetable oil refiner, discovered that the fragrance they gave off when heated not only made people feel good, but also cured his perennial insomnia.For this reason, he opened an essential oil treatment workshop Estrella Chœlus in a small town to treat anxiety, insomnia and depression by heating essential oil.Guests could not only enjoy the fragrance treatment in the store, but also they could buy back…
-
Lingose: Empowering Wed3’s GameFi Players
With the awakening of self-awareness of a new generation of netizens, people begin to realize the value of their actions, and when these lines are recorded and accumulated enough, big data is formed. At present, major companies use big data to make countless profits, but the contributors of the data themselves have nothing to gain. When people really realize this, then web3 will be one step away from us. The most notable feature of Web3 is that the ownership and control of the digital content created by the user belong…
-
OEC (OKEXChain)’s first NFT asset aggregation platform Dematrix will be launched on the mainnet soon
The official opening of the third phase of OKEXChain has opened a new era of DeFi ecology, which is good news for everyone in the blockchain world. OKExChain is the world’s first transaction chain-a blockchain technology infrastructure built for transactions. Through the development of “blockchain middleware” and operational support for transaction scenarios, it reduces the development costs of application developers and improves users’ Trading experience. As an open public chain ecology, anyone can campaign to become an OKExChain super node, or they can issue their own digital assets, create their…
-
US Senate Approves $1.9T Stimulus Plan; Measure Now Returns to the House
The Senate passed President Joe Biden’s $1.9 trillion Covid 19 relief package Saturday, a possible positive development for cryptocurrencies. The measure, which was passed by a 50-49 party-line vote, now heads back to the House, which would have to approve Senate changes to the package before it can head to the president for signing. The House is expected to take up the measure next week, according to The Wall Street Journal. The legislation would provide $300 in weekly unemployment benefits through early September, send $1,400 payments to some Americans and direct…
