Crypto Must Apply Safety Lessons of the Existing Financial System
There is a revealing, albeit slightly morbid, maxim that “safety standards are written in blood.” Humans and human-created systems generally tend to be reactive rather than proactive when it comes to developing protective rules. Nevertheless, today’s construction workers and consumers are more shielded from danger than those of the past because we’ve learned from prior mistakes.
Rick McDonell was the executive secretary of the Financial Action Task Force from 2007 until 2016. Prior to that, he was chief of the United Nations Global Program against Money Laundering at the UNODC. He is now executive director of ACAMS, the Association of Certified Anti-Money Laundering Specialists.
The same dynamic exists in financial regulation, where it could be said that “financial standards are written in fraud.” For example, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission didn’t exist in the first iterations of the stock market. It was only after “Black Tuesday,” the 1929 stock market crash so severe that it was a major contributing factor to the Great Depression, that new laws and regulations were introduced that continue to define modern finance. But the world has morphed into two: the real world and the virtual world. The old rules do not suit either of them.
Parts of the cryptocurrency industry have been culturally slow to accept and implement compliance requirements of the existing (traditional) financial system. This extends from basic know-your-customer (KYC) protocols to the more challenging requirements of the “Travel Rule.” Companies offering services in the crypto industry – commonly called “virtual asset service providers,” or VASPs – need to comply in full force and spirit with global anti-money laundering and counter-terrorism financing conventions or risk being sanctioned or shut out by regulators or criminally pursued by law enforcement if they intentionally breach the law in jurisdictions in which they reside or operate.
For example, the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN), a U.S.-based regulator that is also a bellwether of global financial regulatory enforcement, recently proposed lowering the threshold of the Travel Rule from $3,000 to $250.
See also: Campbell-Verduyn/Moritz Hutten – Is the Travel Rule Good or Bad for Crypto? Both
The Travel Rule requires financial institutions transferring money across international borders to collect and share certain information about the sender and recipient. It is a key tool in the fight against money laundering, terrorism financing, transnational criminal activity and fraud. VASPs that create on-ramps to the crypto economy, enabling the exchange of fiat money for crypto, are clearly a critical link in effective enforcement of the Travel Rule.
It is not lost on regulators that cryptocurrencies, with an ability to transmit value instantly outside the rails of the traditional financial system, present special challenges when it comes to complying with this rule. The existing financial system sits within a reporting framework that enables enforcement of the Travel Rule. Crypto does not.
VASPS SHOULD BE PREPARED TO BE HELD TO THE SAME STANDARDS AS THE REST OF THE FINANCIAL SYSTEM.
Beyond the hundreds of active distributed protocols transferring millions of dollars worth of digital currencies every second, many blockchains tie up value in complex arrangements like decentralized finance (DeFi), layer 2 protocols, sidechains and smart contracts. It is no small challenge to retrofit a system designed for information sharing between centralized, regulated entities to a web of decentralized networks where anyone with an internet connection can participate.
That doesn’t absolve VASPs of responsibility. On the contrary, it makes their participation in enforcing existing rules all the more critical.
Crypto has a perception problem in many countries – created in part by a historical association with ransomware extortionists, exchange hacks, dark web merchants and sanction-evading nations. U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen recently expressed concerns over bitcoin’s association with illicit activities. In a recent survey, more than half of respondents among government and financial compliance professionals said crypto was a risk to the financial system, yet 80% of crypto industry insiders viewed crypto as an opportunity. Clearly, there is much more work to be done to close the gap.
Vocal support from VASPs for a consistent, regulatory regime, such as one outlined by industry advocacy group Coin Center, is one step that industry supporters could take to demonstrate a commitment to legitimacy.
On the other hand, governments should be aggressive in prosecuting VASPs that resist regulatory oversight. The recent enforcement action brought against Tether demonstrates why regulators need to shine a spotlight on this area. In this arena, there is little difference from the traditional finance world. Pursuing bad actors improves faith in the entire system, and deters potential criminal activity in the future.
If VASPs take the concerns of regulators seriously and demonstrate concerted, good-faith efforts to comply with the international financial crime enforcement regime, governments will be more willing to recognize the legitimate, unique benefits cryptocurrencies offer: accessibility, financial inclusion, programmable money and more.
The modern global financial system is one of humanity’s greatest feats of social and economic engineering, centuries in the making. Despite its flaws, it has helped foster an unprecedented era of global economic activity and stability. If the cryptocurrency industry and governments can work together to apply the lessons learned in the painstaking development of the current system, the financial system of the future will be more fair, more productive, more efficient and more accessible than ever before.
Practically speaking, governments have very little incentive to change the rules to accommodate crypto but have significant incentive to insist on a level playing field with traditional financial institutions. While cryptocurrencies and virtual assets are digital, the reality is that VASPs still need to operate out of countries. Governments might be behind the curve on crypto but they are quickly catching up, and VASPs should be prepared to be held to the same standards as the rest of the financial system.
Recommended News
-
FFIL will help Filecoin grow in distributed storage in the multi-chain era
Up to now, the blockchain industry has formed a new technological revolution, in which the concept of distributed ledger has been comprehensively upgraded and optimized, and distributed digital storage has begun to be applied. Filecoin’s mission is to create a distributed, efficient, and powerful infrastructure for social information storage. We believe that humanity’s most valuable resource is information, and Filecoin is passionate about storing and protecting this valuable resource with efficient pricing, distribution, and protection. The launch of IPFS network also started the wave of distributed storage, in which FIL,…
-
The most anticipated chain game at the end of 2021–islandswap
If 2020 is the first year of DeFi’s explosion, then 2021 is undoubtedly the first year of GameFi’s explosion. Axie has become a phenomenon product whose monthly income has surpassed that of Honor of Kings, depicting a broad prospect of chain games for the public. The fitting concept “metaverse”, as well as the upgrading of policy and supervision, have pushed the chain games to a new climax. The shift from the traditional “Free to Play” to “Play to Earn” (P2E) mode has allowed many chain players to take advantage of GameFi. If you…
-
Thales: We’re building a whole new economic system
Thales, the first lightweight, high-performance parallel chain in the Polka ecosystem, has received a $10 million investment from ZKfund, Holo Capital, and Digital Assets Investment, which will be used for the development of Thales’ economic system layer Hayek, DAO governance layer Plato, and storage network layer IPS (IPS-Thales). Introduction to Thales The Thales project is made up of Hayek, an economic system layer, Plato, a DAO governance layer, and IPS, a storage network layer (IPS-Thales). Although the consensus mechanism of Thales is NPOS, unlike Poca, Thales rewards not only…
-
Bitbase The rising star of the blockchain trading platform track
The digital economy is an intelligent stage characterized by the deep mining and integrated application of blockchain, artificial intelligence and big data. In the face of new social conditions, the digital economy is booming, giving full play to the benefits of technological innovation and changing the current technology The way of application is to give play to the empowering role of technology to society. Under the wave of blockchain technology, the breakthrough in the financial field is epoch-making. Various forms of “blockchain+” applications have been launched. Blockchain technology has accelerated…
-
Carbon Pathfinder KAU is available for global subscription, come and participate!
In order to improve the quality of global environmental protection, drive the combination of blockchain technology + environmental protection, and establish a unified global carbon policy and carbon market, the Ministry of Environmental Protection of South Korea and the International Environmental Protection Organization (WWF), Singapore, the United States, Australia, France, etc. jointly initiated the establishment The main body of carbon emission operation, launched the carbon pather KAU, a global ecological civilization construction system that uses blockchain technology to solve the pain points of the current environmental protection and health industry….
-
The Harry Potter Open Financial Matrix will be launched on February 3,2021
Harry Potter open mode financial matrix shock attack, new block chain industry wind direction, Harry Potter open financial matrix will be opened on February 3,2021. Harry Potter open financial matrix HPOM enables the present society, invites you to share the digital new miracle, de-centralized block chain technology, farewell to centralized management 100% asset security 100% decentralized management, stable, efficient and fast, not tampered with. Block chain technology leader Harry Potter open financial matrix, the whole network attack.
-
Uniswap V3 Introduces New License to Spoil Future SUSHIs
Uniswap has licensed the third iteration of its code bank in an apparent move to ward off would-be copycats. The white paper for v3 of the decentralized exchange (DEX) was released Tuesday. In a possible nod to rival project SushiSwap – which copied Hayden Adams’ creation bit by bit – the Brooklyn, N.Y.-based team’s blog post included one section detailing a “business source license” that acts as a time delay for commercial use of the code “for up to two years.” After that point, the code will remain in an open-source GPL license “into…
-
Dubbed the Next Unicorn, zkTube Launches its Mainnet
zkTube is the most advanced scaling solution on Ethereum Layer 2. It has adopted ZK-Rollups that run computations off-chain and submit the validity proof to chain to provide low gas fees, higher transaction throughput for Ethereum, mainnet security, and extra privacy. It has gathered a lot of attention from over 80 countries since its launch in 2020. And the mainnet will be launched on 10th, September, 2021. zkTube Mining Mechanism is Launched zkTube team is continuously working and achieving several milestones. The zkTube mining mechanism has launched. zkTube is the only…
-
Tesla’s Elon Musk Wants Coinbase to Become DOGE-Friendly
Tesla CEO and unabashed dogecoin fan Elon Musk wants the Coinbase exchange to end its “No DOGE Allowed” policy and list the meme-based cryptocurrency. Musk tweeted an exclamatory “Yes” on Saturday after a Twitter user asked the billionaire investor whether Coinbase should enable the Shiba Inu-represented cryptocurrency on its platform. Musk’s Twitter reply.Source: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1370557948494233604 A listing on Coinbase would expose dogecoin to a whole new breed of investor and thus unleash its potential. That’s because the U.S.-regulated exchange is considered synonymous with institutional investors and high net worth individuals. Tesla bought bitcoin worth $1.5 billion…
-
An open global transactionand settlement network protocol
The digital currency represented by Bitcoin is being recognized by mainstream investment institutions, and the core technology behind it, blockchain technology, is also widely received due to the changes brought to the industry during the process of integration with traditional fields. Attention and research. As an emerging technology, blockchain technology has been a hot topic widely discussed both inside and outside the industry from the beginning to the present and to the future. As an emerging technology, the first and largest application scenario of blockchain technology is in the fields…
