Money Reimagined: NFTs Can Learn From DeFi’s Growth
This week, you could be forgiven for thinking bitcoin has ceded ground at the epicenter of the crypto zeitgeist to non-fungible tokens (NFT). Bitcoin’s price dropped to its lowest level since March 8, after failing to consolidate gains made on yet another Elon Musk tweet. Meanwhile, NFT stories were everywhere again. Another Beeple art piece sold for $6 million to raise funds for the Open Earth Foundation’s efforts to fight climate change, and both The New York Times and Time Magazine announced sales of their own NFTs.
It’s also true that bitcoin continues to attract attention in financial troubled parts of the world. There was a spike of interest in Turkey this week as its financial crisis worsened after President Recep Erdoğan got rid of his third central bank governor in less than two years. And there continues to be strong demand for bitcoin in Argentina, the country whose century-long troubles with money are the subject of this week’s edition of our “Money Reimagined” podcast.
We were joined by Lucas Llach, a former vice president of the Central Bank of Argentina, and by Santiago Siri, an Argentine-born crypto developer whose experiences there led him to invent an entirely new, decentralized approach to democracy. Have a listen after you read the newsletter.
NFTs’ Post-Frenzy Future Lies in DeFi
In a recent CoinDesk TV interview, entrepreneur and digital economy maven Gary Vaynerchuk looked at the current mania around non-fungible tokens, with the mind-blowing prices being paid for tokenized digital artifacts, and compared it to the 2000 dot.com bubble.
“Gary Vee,” whose utterances have earned him an Instagram following of 8 million and who will be a keynote at CoinDesk’s Consensus conference in May, meant it as a positive analogy, not a negative reference. Once NFT prices correct to more reasonable levels, he said, it will clear the way for the technology’s true transformative phase, much like the emergence of life-changing social media and mobile computing innovations in wake of the dot.com bust.
You’re reading Money Reimagined, a weekly look at the technological, economic and social events and trends that are redefining our relationship with money and transforming the global financial system. Subscribe to get the full newsletter here.
The question, then, is what’s coming after the hype around NFT deflates?
To explore that, let’s add another, more recent historical comparison: the initial coin offering (ICO) bubble of 2017 and the decentralized finance (DeFi) boom that started last year. That two-step evolution was similar to the internet’s post-dot.com development, but in this case it’s with decentralized, blockchain technologies especially relevant to NFTs.
Integration and composability
The basic dot.com business model during the Web 1.0 era was to convince consumers they should buy their pet food or their socks or their groceries from different e-commerce websites. The problem was each site was easily replicable, which made for a brutal competition in which there could be only a few winners; or, perhaps just one: Amazon.
In the subsequent Web 2.0 phase, developers discovered the real opportunity lay in integrating with other internet applications and services to build audiences through enhanced network effects. We saw an explosion of apps built on the iPhone and Android operating systems, as well as services that tapped Facebook’s and Google’s APIs. The apps and platforms forged symbiotic relationships that expanded the combined ecosystems’ impact, utility and value.
Similarly, DeFi represented a break from the ICO model that preceded it. Whereas the unproven token projects of the ICO boom were mostly standalone ideas with self-contained value propositions, the defining features of DeFi are interoperability and “composability.”
DeFi projects that incentivize participants to add liquidity to decentralized lending markets proactively encourage cross-integration with different protocols and applications, literally building on top of one another. They leverage the value generated by each to grow a wider lending, borrowing and payments ecosystem out of a network of decentralized exchanges, automated market-makers, self-executing collateral systems, trustless price data and stablecoins.
DeFi must overcome scaling and usability challenges before it can fulfill its promise as an alternative, decentralized financial system. But there are already strong lessons to draw from the breathtaking pace of innovation.
For NFT projects, a big one may be that they, too, must integrate with other elements of the open-source, blockchain, fintech and data economy if they’re to add meaningful value to the creative, media and entertainment industry.
Speculation as a service
A second lesson is that speculation, too often derided as a source of excess and scammy behavior, can be your friend. It just needs to serve the project’s objective.
That was not the case for most ICOs. They were built on “utility token” models whereby the underlying ecosystem was projected to grow as users exchanged a programmable token whose features were supposed to incentivize them to act in the common interest. The problem was that investors saw the tokens as get-rich-quick opportunities, as assets to buy and hold in the hope of price appreciation, not as something to exchange and use. There was a conflict between user motivation and intended outcomes.
By contrast, DeFi projects need speculators. Many of the key DeFi components work on the principle that, when traders in financial products seek to profit from market inefficiencies, their buying or selling behaviors will drive prices back toward equilibrium. In effect, speculators profit by removing the inefficiencies and DeFi seeks to harness that.
Thus, MakerDAO’s decentralized platform automatically tweaks fees and collateral requirements to incentivize the profit-seeking actions of borrowers and lenders in ways that achieve one of the platform’s main objectives: to maintain a steady $1 price for dai, the stablecoin in which loans are denominated. Similarly, other DeFi lending platforms have offered special rewards to borrowers and lenders to entice the liquidity they need to grow their platforms.
What about the NFT market? Well, there’s plenty of speculation. But with headlines dominated by a few blowout deals, it might be doing more harm than good.
NFT proponents talk of democratizing arts and entertainment, of empowering up-and-coming artists and independent content creators, and of using this technology to raise money for worthy causes. In theory, the technology could give creators access to a wider potential market and encourage greater transparency to prevent powerful collectors and galleries from setting prices. It might also allow programmable features that automatically deliver some of the secondary market’s proceeds to the original artist or to designated recipients.
But it’s hard to speak of revolution if most of the value is captured by a few celebrity creators – like Beeple, whose $69 million sale was orchestrated by no less of an old-world art market player as Christie’s, or like Jack Dorsey, whose NFT of his first tweet fetched $2.9 million. As with the traditional art market, these high-priced unique assets will likely not find much liquidity in secondary sales by themselves, which means the market itself won’t grow, which in turn won’t help lesser-known artists.
So, again, it’s time to take a leaf out of DeFi’s book. How do you create useful speculation that fosters adoption and innovation?
DeFi-ing NFTs
The answer may lie not only in copying DeFi, but in joining it.
Integrating NFT minting platforms and marketplaces into DeFi’s network of decentralized exchanges and liquidity engines would allow developers of those projects to tap into that ecosystem of self-reinforcing innovation and access its liquidity pools to harness speculation in a constructive way.
A key opportunity lies in the innovative, smart contract-driven approach to collateral management employed by DeFi lending platforms such as Compound, Aave and MakerDAO. After all, art works and collectibles are quite often used as security for loans in the physical world, even when there’s not an especially liquid market for buying and selling them.
Already, startups such as NFTfi are working on a model that enables NFT holders to borrow against their assets in this way.
Meanwhile, if DeFi-based decentralized apps can both incentivize trading of NFTs and automate residual payments to the original creator’s chosen causes whenever a secondary market sale occurs, other radical business ideas might also be possible. In that widening, more diversified market, independent creators of art and other content will find new opportunities to monetize their work, especially if lightweight licensing and copyright solutions can be incorporated.
The good news is that, per this piece by CoinDesk’s Brady Dale, there are quite a number of teams in addition to NFTfi working at the nexus of DeFi and NFTs. The projects do everything from fractionalizing art ownership to creating more sophisticated, automated royalty payment systems.
The post-bubble NFT world might not be as headline-grabbing, but it promises to be more interesting.
Off the charts: The centralizing canal
In the parlance of hackers and crypto people, the Suez Canal is a centralized vector of attack, a single vulnerability that, if it fails, can do great harm to the much bigger system that depends on it. That’s the read of the economic impact of this week’s unfortunate incident in which a massive container ship ran aground in the canal and blocked traffic there for days. Lloyd’s of London estimated that $9.6 billion in goods shipments per day was being stalled by the blockage.
To put this centralized vulnerability into perspective, Shuai Hao and I came up with pie charts to represent the Suez Canal’s place within the global economy. The most significant measure is in dollar value, which may be a function of the fact that a great deal of the world’s oil passes through the canal.
That leads to another point: One decentralizing solution that would reduce the global economy’s dependence on this thoroughfare would be to shift more of the world’s energy consumption to local, renewable sources such as solar and wind. Read last week’s newsletter for a discussion of how bitcoin mining, counterintuitively, could be a catalyst for that.
The conversation: Musk strikes again (and misses?)
Another week, another tweet from Tesla CEO Elon Musk moves the crypto market. This time it was a remark, in the early hours New York time Wednesday, that Tesla is now accepting bitcoin for purchases of its cars.
The important aspect of the policy shift from Tesla was not that the company is accepting bitcoin payments per se but that it is managing the funds itself and won’t convert them into dollars. That “HODLing” part could, in theory, support the price.
Naturally, the usual cast of Tesla and bitcoin enthusiasts weighed in to applaud the move. And, sure enough, over the course of the next five hours, the news helped the largest cryptocurrency add around $3,400, or 6.4%, to post an intraday high of $57,225.
But the gains were short-lived. Within just six hours, the price was back down below where it had been before Musk’s tweet. The failure to consolidate gains seemed to act as a weight on bitcoin, such that by early Thursday morning it had dropped to within just $458 of the $50,000 level.
Why the retreat? Perhaps because there was no there there. At this stage of the bitcoin cycle, people with enough bitcoins to spend on a Tesla are HODLing it, not spending. Maybe a few people will follow Binance CEO Changpeng “CZ” Zhao’s lead and spend their coin on a Tesla. But it’s immaterial to the market. CoinDesk columnist JP Koning had a point:
Relevant reads: Money laundering watchdog
The Financial Action Task Force (FATF), an international alliance of financial regulators, is flexing its muscles toward the crypto industry. New guidance this week, reported by Ian Allison, shows the FATF has DeFi in its sights. It is also tweaking the wording around NFTs that could signal a tougher regulatory hurdle for companies involved in that space.
Moreover, it outlined a stricter line on the “Travel Rule,” which will require virtual asset service providers (VASPs) – i.e., custodial cryptocurrency exchanges – to track their customers’ transfers to self-custody wallets off-platform. This prompted a stern backlash from crypto regulation lobbyists such as Coin Center’s director of research, Peter Van Valkenburgh, who bemoaned the “absolutely inappropriate” surveillance of individuals that the changes would entail.
Undeterred, Rick McDonell, the former executive secretary of the FATF, penned an op-ed for CoinDesk essentially chastising the crypto industry for asking that it be given an easier regulatory standard than that applied to traditional financial institutions.
So, how are crypto businesses responding? The hiring moves by Binance, the global exchange powerhouse, provide a hint. As Danny Nelson reports, Binance has added former FATF officers to its regulatory strategy team.
Recommended News
-
WEB3.0’s first war why FSV is the main field
According to the data survey, it was found that in the current hot wind of the meta-universe, “whether it is a big factory or a startup team, more and more people are entering Web3.0 throughout 2022.” In the promotion of capital and various institutions, the star project FSV in 2022 also began to build FSVSWAP based on FSV smart chain, is expected to complete all main network testing and successful launch in Q4 2022, this FSV build FSVSWAP engine page based on FSV smart chain also marks the era of…
-
Ripple Acquires 40% Stake in Asia Cross Border Payments Firm Tranglo
Cryptocurrency company Ripple has acquired a large stake in an Asia-based cross-border payments specialist in order to meet the growing customer demand. Ripple said Tuesday that it has agreed to acquire a 40% stake in Tranglo for the purpose of expanding its RippleNet On-Demand Liquidity service, according to a press release. Tranglo is a cross-border money and prepaid credit transaction hub providing businesses and individuals the ability to transfer payments globally, according to its website. Southeast Asia’s payments landscape is “highly fragmented,” Ripple said in the release. Each country possesses its…
-
Coinbetter: Keep an eye on investment institutions
In 2021, the growth momentum of DeFi maintained, and the value of locked positions will continue to reach new highs. New trends such as GameFi, Metaverse, and NFT will continue to become popular, and many brands, companies and investment institutions will enter the market one after another. After the downturn in 2020, the blockchain industry investment and financing market finally rebounded in 2021. The number of investment and financing in the first half of the year alone has exceeded that of the whole of 2020. Today, these investment institutions already…
-
SoftBank Financial Group — A Crypto Assets Manager
1. Cryptocurrency Fund CME Group’s Bitcoin futures and NYSE’s Bitcoin futures ETF are milestones in the crypto investing area. The SEC Chairman, Gary Gensler has also stated that he prefers to hold Bitcoin futures funds rather than the cryptocurrency itself, let alone many personal investors. Cryptocurrency investment has a high learning cost, because this is an asset with high volatility, and all participants need to be cautious. For those who are very interested in crypto assets but not interested in buying or holding them, there is still an indirect investment…
-
Staking as an Asset Class? This Swiss Institutional Fund Is Jumping In
While institutional investors around the world are just getting their heads around bitcoin (BTC, -1.43%), asset managers in crypto-friendly Switzerland are heading into staking on next-generation blockchain networks. Announced Friday, Zurich-based investment firm Tavis Digital has partnered with Singapore-based Persistence, a bridge for traditional firms into undiscovered realms such as token staking and decentralized finance (DeFi). Tavis Digital is a spin-off of Tavis Capital, an asset manager regulated by the Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority (FINMA) with about $1.07 billion in assets under management. Nimble and financially sophisticated countries like Switzerland and…
-
Panda Miner desenvolve ainda mais o Cloud Hashpower com a sua Maior Mina de Criptocracia no Cazaquistão Oficialmente Colocada em Operação
O mercado de touro de moeda criptográfica trazido pela Bitcoin é ainda forte, que está cheio de fundos, investidores, e vários projectos. No entanto, existe apenas uma escassez de pessoas que trabalham arduamente para o desenvolvimento. A Panda Miner é exactamente um dos poucos intervenientes pragmáticos no mercado de touros. Ao contrário dos impetuosos participantes no mercado secundário, a Panda Miner opta por se desenvolver mais no campo do “cloud hashpower” em que é melhor. Aproveitando a tendência mineira, aumenta continuamente o investimento para conquistar o mercado, expandir os negócios,…
-
The Vision of Ethanim: Building New Public Chain for the Metaverse
As the advanced version of the digital era, many metaverse applications using multiple digital technologies are approaching us. Blockchain technology makes digital identity unique and digital asset confirmation also becomes possible. It builds a trustworthy economic form and also accelerates the development of metaverse. In the past six months or so, the metaverse conceptual application represented by crypto games has been noticed. Traditional game developers have introduced digital assets and NFT based on blockchain technology into the game precisely to form a new metaverse conceptual game with unified value and…
-
Distributed password authentication systems may be the dark horse of the out-of-the-loop circuit in the future DPAS first in the world is about to see a new wave
On April 25, core members of the DPA community stated in the community that the distributed password authentication track, as a future hotspot, can only bring a new wave of boom if there is innovation at the application level. DPA (Distributed Password Authentication) is the world’s first decentralized distributed cryptographic identity authentication system in line with digital financial standards and distributed blockchain, with reference to the architecture standard decentralized public blockchain ecosystem, fully considering the technical characteristics of identity authentication and network ecological construction needs, in user credit identity management,…
-
Coinfans Cloud hashrate leads the digital mining Bitcoin bull market feast
Cloud hashrate mining has become the mining choice of more and more miners in the past two years. Especially in the current period when currency prices continue to soar and break new highs continuously, Cloud hashrate mining has become an important magic weapon to seize the Bitcoin bull market. Cloud hashrate mining, as the name suggests, usually refers to the computing power leasing service provided by large mining farms. Miners users can purchase computing power contracts on the mining platform, thereby earning the bitcoins mined by the corresponding computing power. www.bi-fans.com…
-
B2W Create a safe, transparent and standardized trading environment
B2W has the world’s leading financial technology research and development, blockchain research and development, artificial intelligence systems, big data platforms, the world’s top financial data docking center, currency market transactions, professional asset management, and core ICO community technologies and services. In the field of professional encrypted assets, it provides a series of services for global investment institutions and investors, combines the global currency revolution with financial cutting-edge technology, and provides members of the world with prosperous, healthy and sustainable wealth. Six advantages Avoid human weakness Make decisions objectively…
